"Man, this year has the worst weather ever!", David said as he sat crouched in the small cave where we had sought shelter from yet another sudden rainstorm.
"Nuh-uh!", Diana immediately replied in her traditional know-it-all manner.
"Is too!", David countered cunningly. Terrific. Not only were we stuck in this cave, now we would have to listen to those two nagging for at least an hour. It was time to cut this discussion short.
"Big nuh-uh. In fact, 93 years ago it had already rained five times as much by this time of year."
"Duh", David capitulated, "so it's the worst weather in 93 years then."
"Nuh-uh, this is actually the worst weather in 23 years.", Diana again broke in.
"Yeah, well, whatever", David sighed, "Who cares anyway?".
Well, dear contestants, you care, don't you?
Your task is to, given information about the amount of rain during different years in the history of the universe, and a series of statements in the form "Year X had the most rain since year Y", determine whether these are true, might be true, or are false. We say that such a statement is true if:
The amount of rain during these two years and all years between them is known.
It rained at most as much during year X as it did during year Y.
For every year Z satisfying Y < Z < X, the amount of rain during year Z was less than the amount of rain during year X.
We say that such a statement might be true if there is an assignment of amounts of rain to years for which there is no information, such that the statement becomes true. We say that the statement is false otherwise.